When the Unexpected Happens, Should You Give Up Your Dream or Keep Chasing It?

Amy Kenworthy, Chelsea Gill, Olga Rudneva, Yaryna Boychuk
|
Date of publication: 17 july 2026
|

How should managers respond when, even with a clear strategy, allocated resources, and partner support, external circumstances suddenly derail the original plan? A new educational mini-case study, “When the Unexpected Happens: Should You Give Up Your Dream or Keep Chasing It?”—developed by researchers at Ivey Business School and the UCU Business School—analyzes complex managerial decisions in the context of war.

What is this educational mini-case about?

In June 2022, four months into Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Olga Rudneva, along with her partners Andriy Stavnitser and Philip Grushko, was developing the concept for Superhumans, a free high-tech prosthetics and rehabilitation center. With the support of the Lviv city administration, the entrepreneurs had already secured a building for the future complex.

However, without any warning, the founders received an invitation to the opening of a new municipal prosthetics center, Unbroken, established by the city government. Faced with shock and the sudden loss of their premises and agreements, the leaders were confronted with a dilemma: join the government project, continue on their own path without a building or funding amid the war, or abandon their dream entirely.

Why is this experience unique in the world? Lessons for business education

This mini-case is designed for use in MBA programs and courses on organizational behavior, leadership, decision-making, and social entrepreneurship. The material serves as an ideal platform for students and experienced top managers to assess their readiness to make decisions amid catastrophic or unpredictable changes.

The case offers business education the following key lessons and insights:

  • Managing the Unplanned: A practical analysis of how leaders should respond when carefully crafted plans are disrupted by external factors.
  • The Importance of Experience and Team Commitment: An exploration of how founders’ business experience, a strong team, and commitment to their vision help find a way out of seemingly hopeless situations.
  • The Adaptability of Social Entrepreneurship: An understanding of the motivations of leaders who strive to create social value and transform the country even in the absence of seed capital or existing infrastructure.
  • The Limits of Strategic Flexibility: An assessment of the criteria by which a manager should decide whether to change the operational model, maintain autonomy, or integrate with other initiatives.

Case Study Overview

You can access the full version of the educational case study directly on the Ivey Publishing platform at the following link: Case Study: When the Unexpected Happens, Should You Give Up Your Dream or Keep Chasing It? | Ivey Publishing.

Read more on the subject